2017 NFL Redraft: Rebuilding the first round based on PFF grades and data
Published on Tuesday, 22 July 2025 at 1:16 am
The NFL Draft is a fascinating, often unpredictable spectacle. Teams invest millions and years of scouting into selecting the next generation of talent, yet even the most meticulous processes are imperfect. What if we could hit the rewind button, armed with the full knowledge of how careers unfolded? Thanks to Pro Football Focus's comprehensive database, which meticulously grades every player on every snap, we can do exactly that. We can travel back to the 2017 NFL Draft and construct a first round based not on pre-draft hype or potential, but on the cold, hard reality of on-field production and impact as captured by PFF's unparalleled data. This isn't just a hypothetical exercise; it's a profound look at how value truly emerges in the NFL, offering a masterclass in the power of hindsight and objective performance metrics.
SEO Keywords:
Looking backthe original 2017 draft class was lauded for its potentialparticularly at quarterback. Howeverhindsight reveals a seismic shift in the hierarchy. The most glaring exampleof courseis Patrick Mahomes. Originally selected 10th overall by the Kansas City ChiefsMahomes would undoubtedly be the consensus first overall pick in any redraft. His unprecedented PFF gradesmultiple MVP awardsand Super Bowl championships cement his status as a generational talenta stark contrast to the quarterback taken second overall in realityMitchell Trubiskywhose career trajectory saw him quickly fall out of the starter conversation. This dramatic reordering at the top highlights the inherent risk in projecting college talent and the immense value of PFF
Source: pff
